In this blog post, Nick Wolven ponders the fading interest in space exploration, and considers ways to reframe SF narratives in response. Read his new story, “Rocket Jock”, in our [November/December issue, on sale now.]
My story for this issue of Asimov’s is a coming-of-age tale, a domestic drama, an experiment in near-future scene-setting—and an attempt to wrestle with a question that’s been nagging at me lately. Have we, as a culture, fallen out of love with space?
Some residual fascination with the final frontier still lingers, as evidenced by the popularity of the Artemis mission pics and the success of blockbuster, pop-science-infused flicks like Interstellar, The Martian, and Project Hail Mary. But the old, deep yearning for offworld exploration, which drove so much cultural and technological innovation throughout the twentieth century, has mostly given way to either bitter skepticism or formulaic escapism. For modern storytellers, outer space tends to be little more than a convenient stock setting for exotic escapades, as fundamentally fantastical as Oz or Middle-Earth. For more serious thinkers, space exploration has come to be seen as a frivolous diversion from more immediate problems like climate change, inequality, and political extremism—or, worse, as the distinctive obsession of megalomaniacs, colonizers, and creeps. Even while important work continues in the related fields of rocketry, robotics, and exoplanet discovery, the romance of extraterrestrial travel has been lost.
It’s not hard to understand why. The space mania of the mid-twentieth century became something of a victim of its own success. The ’50s, ’60s, and ’70s were boom years for space travel and space-related stories, as real-world advances and fictional inventions drove a burgeoning, widespread fascination with the stars. A productive synergy developed between art and science: major breakthroughs in relevant technologies inspired speculative tales of wonder and awe, which in turn helped unlock support for further study. Hard as it may be to believe now, seventies intellectuals, made giddy by this self-reinforcing cycle, once busily hatched near-term proposals to build orbital settlements, make contact with aliens, harvest the “resources” of the Solar System, and launch expeditions to proximate stars.
It may be only natural that such a boom would eventually give way to a bust. As scientists learned more about what space travel entailed, the dream of establishing off-Earth settlements collapsed into a morass of seemingly insoluble problems. Works like Kelly Weinersmith’s A City on Mars and Adam Becker’s More Everything Forever elaborate in grim detail on the challenges of mounting even modest space settlements, where tiny variations in gravity, light cycles, background radiation, available nutrients, and environmental chemistry can have disastrous effects on human health. That’s to say nothing of the social challenges of sustaining human communities in small, remote, cramped artificial habitats. The problem isn’t just that there are a million details for the devil to hide in, but that, in the absence of Earth’s robust support networks, the consequences of getting one of those details wrong are catastrophic. The main obstacle to settling space is a punishing cost-benefit analysis: massive risks and expenses incurred for wholly uncertain rewards.
As challenging as near-Earth exploration may be, though, most stories of cosmic adventure depend on feats that are flat-out impossible to achieve. The stars are too far away to be settled using plausible technologies, even allowing for enormous advances in propulsion, energy use, and radiation shielding. An underdiscussed problem is the dearth of useful analogies. Standard narratives of interstellar exploration tend to draw on maritime tropes and themes inherited from the age of exploration, when sailing ships funded by mercantilist empires pursed trade and conquest on the high seas. We humans, creatures of convention that we are, love to dress up old tales in dramatic new trappings. But the literature of high-seas adventure, even disregarding its political implications, is just a terrible template for imagining what it might be like to travel to other stars. Such familiar sci-fi staples as spaceships, space colonies, galactic empires, interplanetary trade networks, and so on, are more appropriate to an ocean-based setting than a cosmic one, where extreme distances and hostile conditions make familiar political arrangements impracticable. That’s not to say these tropes have no place, only that they cater to fantasies of the past while offering little guidance for envisioning the future.
For modern storytellers, outer space tends to be little more than a convenient stock setting for exotic escapades, as fundamentally fantastical as Oz or Middle-Earth.
Because of this growing divide between science fiction and science fact—because our dreams of space travel have grown steadily more detached from reality—passion for the subject has taken on a vaguely reactionary cast. Sad to say, serious interest in space is now increasingly associated with aging, rich men whose privileges allow them to overindulge in outmoded boyhood dreams. Stunt rocket flights staged by preening tech moguls inspire more cynicism than wonder or awe, typically becoming fodder for dunks, memes, and viral takedowns. Rocket mishaps are occasions for schadenfreude. Even legitimate scientific breakthroughs are overshadowed by familiar culture-war disputes. To add historical insult to present-day injuries, journalists like Becker and Jill Lepore have documented the ways in which the history of Western futurism is infested with writings from cranks, protofascists, kooks, and other unsavory types, making earnest interest in the subject feel either unsavory or naive. Many authors seem almost to delight in pouring cold water on the dream of someday leaving Earth to explore other worlds.
These jaundiced arguments certainly succeed on the merits: space exploration is, so far as we know, as impractical as they claim. But they feel to me a bit premature, as blinkered in their way as the fantasies they deplore. I’m not quite ready to give up on the romance of space travel just yet, for three reasons.
First, the same cognitive limits that prevent us from comprehending interstellar distances also make it hard to understand long spans of time. Cultural evolution moves very, very quickly by biological, geological, or astronomical standards. A few hundred thousand years ago, humans were living in small bands, foraging for food, and using stone axes. A few thousand years ago, the first major states had begun to appear. A few hundred years ago we’d just gotten started on the Industrial Revolution. And a few decades ago the modern internet had yet to develop. These timeframes are tiny. Who’s to say what might happen over the next few hundred thousand years? I doubt we’ll rewrite the laws of physics, but we might significantly alter our biology, master the art of ecological engineering, develop novel social arrangements, and make huge strides in nanotechnology or materials science or robotics—if we don’t destroy ourselves entirely, that is. Over a million years? That’s a blip for the Earth, but an inconceivably long time in cultural terms. I think we should be humble not only about our current technological and political limitations, but our ability to imagine what kinds of changes the long future might bring.
Second, skeptics of space exploration often urge us to redirect our efforts toward immediate, real-world, terrestrial problems: climate change, ecological collapse, political dysfunction, and so on. But the solutions to these problems, if we can find them, would also be essential to sustaining offworld habitats, where the problem of living within limits is acute. There’s a meaningful interplay, in other words, between the narrow problem of surviving in space and the broader challenge of thriving on Earth. The two goals aren’t necessarily opposed, even if the second takes precedence over the first. The road that might eventually lead to settling other planets begins with pressing, present-day efforts to live in harmony with our own.
Finally, I still believe it’s true that the wonders of space can be a stimulus to science, culture, social progress, and art. We just need new metaphors, new stories, new ways of imagining what space exploration entails. What might it mean to reach into the void, to really get out there, to inhabit—even if only in a small-scale way—that almost unimaginable expanse of emptiness? If the old maritime analogies are moribund, what new analogies might take their place? If space exploration isn’t really like going somewhere—because you can’t get anywhere interesting within the relevant timeframes—then what is it like? Will it be an essentially vicarious experience, as future probes travel out to distant worlds and send back their findings to future generations? Or a mystical one, as we learn more about the nature of realms we can never touch? We’re traveling in space right now, of course, riding the Earth around the Sun, tugged by the Sun around the galactic core; we know it’s happening, we just don’t think about it much. And if we do think about it, we can’t grasp the concept, can’t intuitively make sense of it. Maybe this is what space travel will always feel like, even if we eventually learn to exert more control over the process: like something that happens slowly in the background, out of mind, at scales beyond human comprehension.
Whatever the case, I’m still intrigued by the narrative possibilities of intimate stories set against the awesome backdrop of the stars. Life is short. Trends fade, the zeitgeist shifts; even cynicism eventually goes out of fashion. It may be that we’ll soon rediscover our romance with space exploration, even as we’re compelled by human limits to take hesitant, baby steps toward the stars. If so, the world will once again have a need for space explorers of many stripes—for adventurers and heroes, but also technicians and functionaries…for scientists, strivers, storytellers, service workers…and for rocket jocks, and the girls who love them…